News Release-EPD Arrests Suspect in Attempted Robbery, Battery Investigation, 11.18.26
News Release-Suspect Arrested in Attempted Robbery, Battery Investigation, 11.18.26
Yesterday the Elkhart County Police Department arrested a male suspect who allegedly battered two women during an attempted robbery after following them home from a bank.
On November 17, 2026, at about 4:23 p.m., Elkhart Police Department officers were dispatched to 300 E Crawford Street for what was originally reported as some type of fight.
Upon arrival at the intersection of E Crawford St/Grove St an officer observed multiple people in the street, but no active fighting. Two female victims reported that an unknown male suspect followed them from Old National Bank (320 N. Main St) to this location and then ran up to them and demanded money after they exited their vehicle. He did not display a weapon. The victims refused to hand over the money and an altercation ensued. One female victim reported that the man struck her in the abdomen during the altercation and kept trying to grab her purse. During the incident the man dropped some cards, including an ID. After failing to obtain the money the male suspect left the area in a Jeep.
The female victims reported minor injuries and pain from the incident. During the investigation, an EPD officer located a Jeep Grand Cherokee matching the victims’ description using Flock and obtained a license plate number. Shortly after 5:00 p.m., a third EPD officer conducted a traffic stop at 740 Prairie St on a Jeep matching the victims’ description and with the same license plate number. During the stop, the officer detained the alleged male suspect, who matched the ID dropped at the scene.
The male suspect, identified as Demetrius Sturgis, 28 years old of Elkhart, was arrested and booked into the Elkhart County Jail on preliminary charges in connection with this incident. Today an Elkhart County judicial officer found probable cause for his arrest on preliminary charges of one count of Attempted Robbery, a Level 3 Felony, and two counts of Battery, each a Class A Misdemeanor. He was ordered held without bond until his initial hearing on November 24, 2026. This case has been forwarded to the Elkhart County Prosecutor’s Office for review of formal criminal charges.
Please be advised that under Indiana law an individual is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.
<end>
Contact Us
City of Elkhart
229 South Second Street
Elkhart Indiana, 46516
Phone: 574-294-5471
Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday
8 AM - 5 PM EST